| 1990 |
| Daniel Roughton |
1959 - Football |
| Chester Jastremski |
1959 - Swimming |
| Paul Harshman |
1960 - Football |
| Vince King |
1962 - Wrestling |
| Paul Elzey |
1964 - Football/Wrestling |
| Daniel Harshman |
1964 - Football |
| Richard Mattingly |
Coach |
| Robert Recker |
Coach |
| 1991 |
| Terry Brown |
1962 - Football |
| William Huff |
1964 - Football/Wrestling |
| Karl Pankratz |
1966 - Football/Wrestling |
| R. Martin Huff |
1967 - Football |
| Thomas Schlageter |
1968 - Football |
| 1992 |
| Dennis Spencer |
1960 - Golf |
| Randall Whately |
1970 - Football/Tennis |
| Andrew Huff |
1968 - Football |
| Marc Schlatter |
1976 - Swimming |
| Michael Kennedy |
1977 - Football |
| 1993 |
| Bill Murtagh |
1970 - Swimming |
| Bob Wilczynski |
1967 - Baseball |
| Bill Jaco |
1975 - Football |
| Tom Walinski |
1960 - Football |
| 1994 |
| Nelson Bolden |
1977 - Football |
| Phil Buerk |
1964 - Wrestling |
| John Wiza |
1969 - Football |
| Paul Peer |
1979 - Baseball/Football |
| 1984 Football Team |
| 1995 |
| 1964 Wrestling Team |
| Bob Utter |
1973 - Baseball |
| Dan Hylant |
1968 - Swimming |
| David Marker |
1968 – Swimming |
| Chris D’Esposito |
1984 - Football |
| 1996 |
| 1983 Basketball Team |
| John Drauer |
1959 - Basketball |
| Bill Rienbolt |
1970 - Wrestling |
| Brian Rowan |
1979 - Basketball |
| Richard Lishewski |
1983 - Football |
| 1997 |
| Thomas Guitteau |
1959 - Football |
| Jim Gerken |
1972 - Baseball |
| Scott Bittinger |
1984 - Basketball |
| Brad Wotring |
1986 - Cross Country |
| 1967 Swimming Team |
| 1968 Swimming Team |
| 1998 |
| Emerson J. Ross, Jr. |
1959 - Football |
| Gregory Zann |
1967 - Swimming |
| Tim Gerken |
1976 - Baseball |
| Tom Karpinski |
1984 - Football |
| 1970 Wrestling Team |
| 1999 |
| Jim Lehner |
1966 - Cross Country |
| Gary Bryan |
1974 - Cross Country |
| Alan Harberson |
1981 - Football |
| Todd Mitchell |
1984 - Basketball |
| 2000 |
| Pete Malone |
1967 – Swimming |
| Ed Urbaniak |
1973 – Basketball |
| Brian Shire |
1984 – Wrestling |
| Denny McNamara |
1985 – Baseball/Football |
| 2002 |
| 1966 Football Team |
| Steve Skiver |
1967 - Football |
| Doug Finch |
1978 - Wrestling |
| Shawn Reid |
1983 - Basketball |
| 2004 |
| Jim Kubacki |
Coach |
| Jeff Guyton |
1972 – Wrestling |
| Pat Delaney |
1983 – Football/Basketball |
| Todd Dominiak |
1984 – Tennis |
| 2006 |
| Ron Soviar |
1972 – Track |
| Mike Nicholson |
1985 – Football/Baseball |
| 1996 Swim Team |
| 2008 |
| Larry Moreland |
1961 - Basketball |
| Brian Burns |
1985 - Football/Hockey/Baseball |
| Tom Takats |
1992 - Football/Basketball/Baseball |
| 1998 Swimming and Diving Team |
|
